Adam gave me a pair of Vibram Five Fingers for Christmas. I was really excited to try them out but they were way too big. The odd thing was that he ordered me european size 41, which should be somewhat smaller than my actual foot size. I’m a US 9 for those wondering.

I sat on them for a while because Adam couldn’t find his receipt and I figured Vibram’s policy would be no receipt no return, however after contacting them last month they graciously exchanged the shoes for a smaller pair, a set of women’s european 40.

Unfortunately, I still can’t use them because the 40’s are entirely too small. I had forgotten about righting this situation until I read an article on how modern shoes really aren’t that good for our feet a few moments ago. I’ve initiated the email support process with Vibram who I hope will continue to be as great as they have been in the past and help me figure out what has gone wrong.

My initial thought is that the first pair was improperly manufactured and the sizing was wrong. The 41 was about 3/4 inch too big on my heel. That is pretty significant. The 40 is about half an inch too small (although estimating this is hard since I can only hold the shoe against the bottom of my foot) and ends up making my toes curl. There must be some sort of in between!

The other possibility is that somehow my feet just aren’t cut out for the model I’ve received. I think I could deal with a shoe that is too large if I had a strap across the foot like one of their new models, the sprint. At least with that model I’d have the strap as well as the heel chord holding my foot in.

I hope I can get this straightened out soon. I keep forgetting about it and placing it on the back-burner, but it would be so wonderful to take an outing in these shoes that seem to get such rave reviews everywhere. If you have a pair and enjoy them, I’m curious if you felt the sizing was true-to-size.